Hey @burlarj
What you propose already exists in certain parts of the world and it is not working out.
Ask China LOL
I also think it is funny that when people see problems in the world they go for blame and authoritative control based of loose facts.
We are not over populated we are badly managed in my opinion.
If we are being as strict as you want to be do you think there is room in the world under this new state you created for us for any freedom or free thinking.
I doubt it.
The kind of places that have these kinds of rigid control would not let you have your freedoms either.
Taking freedom from someone means someone will take yours from you too, all you have to do is look at actual history.
We also have to consider you have one solution for population control, someone elses maybe even more stricter cause these things always goes in one direction or another depending on who holds the power.
There are a lot of people that would not exist in your world, i think it would be much more different that you could imagine.