Part 3/8:
Let’s first take a closer look at Pete Alonzo. At 30 years old, Alonzo’s peak, which he reached during his rookie season, seems distant as his performance has gradually waned. While he has managed to hit over 40 home runs in the years following that rookie year, 2024 marked his worst statistical performance, with a career-low OPS and only 34 home runs.
Alonzo’s trajectory raises red flags. After accumulating an impressive 6 WAR in his rookie season, he has failed to surpass 4.5 WAR in any subsequent season, with a disappointing 2.6 WAR recorded last year. His defensive performance has further compounded these issues; his fielding at first base was among the lowest in the league, coupled with subpar base running metrics.