Thank youi for your update and examples using Python.
As @eniolw pointed out, I need to disclose the source of what I'm saying even if the source is mostly simple highschool level math. Making it vissible with a bit of python though should prove enlightning to some.
I'm not sure how you derived that conclusion, but my earlier comment wasn't about your math. I was actually pointing out that it would help if you linked to the specific claims made by Professor Dave that you're questioning. It's all about backing up what we say with evidence so people can see for themselves and we can keep things credible.
Also, I noticed you're making a sweeping statement about Professor Dave's work based on one issue. But without showing us the error and its context, it's tough to take that leap. I'm going to assume there's been a mix-up with what I said before, but let's try to avoid feeding the haters without a good reason.