I have to say- I agree with @bronko, completely.
"accounts with a completely normal deck and no harmful behavior will have to rent CP unnecessarily. This doesn’t make sense"
Setting up another, completely arbitrary, hoop for accounts to jump through- in order to play or earn, doesn't make sense.
Especially in a format called "Wild"
That said- I fully support any proposal to institute Barriers to Entry for new players. The more complicated, involved, arbitrary, and esoteric the barrier is, the better.
U do know that Bronko also has a proposal up that requires u to have CP, but u can't rent it, u will have to buy cards to earn something, here u can still rent, unless his gets voted down we can get that.
Absolutely. I know all about @bronko's other proposal. It's, as you say, basically the same; there's just a change to one word in his statement:
"accounts with a completely normal deck and no harmful behavior will have to
rentown CP unnecessarily. This doesn’t make sense"Everything I said applies, just as much, to the original proposal as it does to this one- restrictions in a format called "Wild", don't make sense.
OTOH: any pro-bot/anti-player proposals, such as these, will always receive my hearty approval and endorsement.
there are also other differences in my proposal.
There were a few other differences between the proposals too
and a few more little differences.
Overall your original proposal was simpler, easier to program, easier implement and made more sense while also being much more punishing toward new players.
You are right.
I had to double-check this one- there IS a requirement for Bronze! Which just seems dumb but who am I to say?
Thats even creazier would destroy the rental mkt
Yes like mine i own my cards and now i need to re distribute some of my main to my alts for no reason other than to get cp