Here is my feedback:
This proposal is untimely. There is no rush needed to change any of these.
I felt after reading the discussion briefly that there was limited participation among guilds
For all the other things that we need to change in the game, I feel this is low priority.
That said, you can bring any proposal you like. However, people are free to react as they please on them.
That's fair, I'm not super partial on this issue either way. The discussion met the threshold for bringing forth a proposal based on the placeholder guidelines. The conversation made it pretty apparent to me that we do need to address this issue at some point though. I never really put much thought into why we sit at the top of tier 3 instead of advancing. I remember someone saying it was better for us to stay there and earn more and I just kind of forgot about it tbh. That said... it clearly isn't working as intended if guilds are refusing to advance to tier 4 or tier 5 as they make more in tier 3 or 4 for less effort is it? This reminds me of the whole "why build a champion deck when I can build x number of bronze decks and get more rewards" argument and we can see how bot farms ran with that...