I am downvoting this proposal as I feel quite strongly that there is a better proposal out there, specifically this: https://peakd.com/hive-13323/@khazrakh/lets-fix-the-brawl-system-take-2
Conceptually, I agree with some of what's in here. However it's not entirely clear (unlike the other proposal linked above). I'm fully in favor of making brawl improvements, just want to make sure the proposal we back is the best one that's currently available.
I have no issues with anyone downvoting and I like KH's idea too. My main focus is eliminating the extra bonus merits and crowns for the top 3 in each tier. I feel this creates a situation where we are building a moat around the top few guilds and this actually creates a perverse disincentive to future competition.
Ok so it sounds like there's been a good discussion between @clayboyn @khazrakh, @xsuilx, and @azircon at the DAO townhall where the conclusion was that this is a step in the right direction. I trust my guildmates, and so I will switch to an upvote.
Cool Brave! I wasn't on the townhall, but I heard the same thing from KH.
To further clarify - I don't disagree with the direction, I just think there's a better execution out there to achieve the objective of improving brawl rewards.