the proposal seems to be fraudulent. no matter if we vote yes or no. someone seems to have independently determined that these cards will go into circulation and we only decide if they go to dao or splinterlandstv.
then I definitely decide for splinterlandstv even if I do not like the giveaway bot!
but actually it should not be that someone determines that the dao right to buy will be used in any case and the cards come into circulation.
may i also determine that the dao buys 1000 cards for me. and you only have the choice to say yes i may use the right to buy for me or if you later vote no then it gets my little brother...
the proposal should only be. may the dao make use of the right to buy yes or no! if yes comes out you can make a proposal to decide what happens to the cards and if no the cards have to be burned without if and but!
Hey @bronko this isn't fraudulent, its a proposal but made quickly because we don't have a lot of time to claim these.
If the DAO community doesn't pass this, which it likely will, then we can also burn the cards. Remember that if this doesn't pass, then nothing said in this proposal means anything. So if cards are made before the process finishes and the outcome is unknown, then in reality if it passes then we would have to burn the cards because we didn't have authorization from anyone to make them.
You are being very technical, and bringing up a valid point, but just because something isn't written perfectly doesn't mean the intention is bad. In this case, we are trying to rush a proposal due to a time constraint to get the cards made for the DAO. If the proposal doesn't pass, then all that happens is the cards should be burned.
I don't like these rushed proposals. I don't want this to be a precedent. I voted no here but will probably vote yes in the official SPS vote.
That's fair on both accounts. We are trying to do our best but definitely finding out that many people don't like to rush things. We are discussing taking it down as well. Thanks for the input @johnhtims.thrds
I'm thinking maybe we should just have an official dao proposal where the DAO will claim ALL FUTURE free airdrops like this in the future. That will prevent any more rushed votes and also prevent having to constantly do a vote for every single future airdrop. I would vote yes on that for sure.
good idea.