dude. no. you don't get to be the sole arbiter of what makes it to the proposal stage. if someone wants to spend 100k DEC to put a suggestion out, you shouldn't be able to stop it. that defeats the purpose of a "community" based ecosystem. Also, why are you trying to limit proposals to just DAO or SPS related topics. what if someone wants to make a proposal that you don't get to do this task anymore? you can just shut it down now. pretty dictatorial position don't you think?
You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
I'm pretty sure you didn't read it properly, if someone wants to put forward a proposal and burn 100k DEC then they can, they always will be able to.
Claymore just decided what proposals the DAO pays for and proposes as it uses the DAOs DEC, and proposals the DAO propose should be just related to DAO things. That's why he says there are certain things a proposal should be able, because it's solely about the DAO.
I quote from the above "If you'd like to submit a proposal for something along those lines, you will need to burn the 100,000 DEC and do it yourself."
I'm pretty sure I've seen proposals from other people not just from clayboyn. So, that means he's not gatekeeping the proposals. He's only managing the DAO side, in which, is his job in the first place.
Asking him not to be the arbiter of what DAO does is like asking the spokesperson to not speak for the president. That's part of his job. If your idea though is anyone can pass proposal through DAO without anyone checking for it, then it would be a resource waste because I'm pretty sure a lot of people would be passing proposals for their own benefits, which defeats the purpose of the proposals used for the benefits of the most.
TLDR, the proposals coming from DAO are mostly requests from people that the DAO find interesting.
If you think that it's dictatorial position and unfair, then you can gather 100k DEC (I suggest finding a group or sponsor of some sort) then once funded, you can submit to change what Clayboyn was assigned to, or even change DAO itself. I do think that's possible IF the communty agrees.