You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: SPS Governance Proposal - Adjust Brawl Rewards

in #spsproposal11 months ago

We done the compromise that the Top-3-Bonus should continue for SPS but not for crowns and merrits.
This bonus for crowns and merrits add for top-guilds a huge advantage as they can buy more gladius-cards and have than better cards for next brawl, on addition they get more merrits and can upgrade their building quicker.
When it leads to the result that one guild play with silver-level-gladius-cards and the other with max-level-gladius-cards this is not a fair competition or would you take part in a car race on foot?

Sort:  

My friend... I have been getting shit stomped by higher level Gladius cards since I started Brawling.

That is the nature of the beast... however, to your point, you are incorrect because only in the top Tiers/Frays where you can play Top Gladiators will that have any true effect.

For my guild, Bitcoin and Brews, we play Tier 3 as that's as far as we've advanced since early 2022.

We're not rich, we're not bots and we don't win every single Brawl... but we DO win... Gladiator cards are great... but they don't win games by themselves... unless they're named Quora Towershield lol...

I think we should uncap the restriction but I am actually FOR keeping the Top 3 Bonus... I mean... that's why it's competitive right?

Otherwise, just load a Fray, pop in a Chaos Agent, take the L and get the same amount of SPS/Merits/Crowns as if you tried and got 6th or something...

One moment my friend, maybe you missunderstand one point - the Top-3-bonus won't be taken completely away, he will (when the proposal is successfull) only removed for Crowns and Merrits but he should stay for the SPS-rewards.
So the proposal won't change anything in the top-3-bonus regarding SPS (at least if 10 or more guilds are in the Tier - not the brawl - ).
To take away the reward reduction for Tiers with less than 10 guilds seems very logical - this will probably only apply for Tier 5 - but why guilds who invested in the store can enjoy the merrit bonus but guilds who invested in the arena will be cutted down be the reward reduction factor.
This factor was usefull to prevent that the first guild who reach Tier 5 will win a very huge amount of merrits but now it has lost his sense as it was enogh time to bring Arena to Level 9 (I mean for the top-10-guilds)