{NO}
I honestly think some of the other proposals are more interesting. I mainly made this one to gauge interest in more aggressive play, so the probability isn't very well adjusted. It would indeed work better with a proper rewards % like 1/3, or maybe a lower land cost.
Hmmmm... I think I know my next proposal. That more than one proposal be available for vote during the voting phase. Selecting just one means the direction of the game can technically be manipulated by the Totem, given we've got no input and so which proposal of a set of equally "likable" proposals is chosen depends on the totems choice entirely.
Maybe some rules for more proposals up to vote or some way for us to affect which proposal is the official one.
Posted using Partiko Android
You're right in that the selection of the official proposal is out of the player's hands, but I'm not selecting the proposals arbitrarily. I selected your proposal as yours was the only one from a player that had yet to submit a successful proposal. But I highly encourage the players to define new mechanisms which remove this power away from the Totem and directly onto the players, although it might take some coordination...