You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: My problem with Communism

in #communism7 years ago

Hmm, you excluded the begining of Hirearchy, which was your "problem word" to point out, otherwise known as selective bias fallacy, that it says authority, and I pointed out that you're selective bias was a fallacy, and now I have a PROBLEM WORD?

Yup, your brain is actually not processing correctly if you don't see the contradiction in that.

What is the contradiction (facepalm)

I really don't know what you are trying to say here, bro. I think I broke you. Sorry, I tend to brake things I play with :)

Asshole said what:

For some reason you tried to bring camp- thinking and a vs-mentality into the debate with me. Not sure why you are so triggered.

I said this:

Demonstrate I did that asshole.

Sort:  

lol, I have committed a "selective bias was a fallacy" by copy pasting the definition of organization. Sorry that I did not include the parts that were meaningless.

"What is the contradiction (facepalm)" Nah at this point my social self is fed up. Use your abomination of a brain to figure it out yourself.

Well, I only turn the cheek so often. But I am no person that does not grant merci:

"Vengeance can imply retribution, they mean exactly the same things."

"can" is the import word here, it indirectly states that vengeance does not imply retribution at least some of the time. Therefore the only none contradicting statements you could have made are:

"Vengeance implies retribution, they mean exactly the same things."

"Vengeance can imply retribution, they sometimes mean exactly the same things."

I would rather agree with the 2nd statement but anyways getting hung up about what is the right definition is not healthy. We should just agree on one and move on to actually discussing topics instead of words.

... you agreed on the punishment of outlawing murderers (Vogelfreiheit). Yet you still argue that punishment is wrong as a concept.

Definitions in dictionaries are just a mere reflection of the most common definitions. So we just need to get the definition straight for us at this point. Punishment is for me preventing the incident to happen again and resocialize the person in question. I don't want to condition criminal humans, I want to help them

Punishment is wrong you idiot because we agreed in the beginning it doesn't work.

I never agreed on that. Who is this "we"?

'Making a thing whole again' or what you call 'resituation' is a concept that has been frowned upon in any decent philosophy. Things change, I hope you do too some day