The web3 stigma

We've been doing quite a bit of work on holozing "under the hood" so to speak which has quite frankly forced our future vision to be more under the hood than we like. It's not an issue per se, we've always meant for the game to be stand-alone even as a non "web3" game, thus our focus on the artwork, the gameplay and mechanics and future additions such as professions and general uniqueness of the idea and broad selection of games we want to add to the ecosystem while using the same assets to access them.

During talks with other projects and companies its been made abundantly clear that the general web2 space is very, very against web3. It doesn't matter how fair or nicely you've launched a project, that founders and team have to buy into your own ecosystem to be vested in its future. The sentiment of the masses that have driven the web3, play2earn, etc, narrative have 99/100 times lead to scams, theft and general shadiness. It's clear to see that most are being driven mainly for the people interested in earning and trading rather than those actually having fun and wanting to invest their free time in a gaming ecosystem that'll value them compared to pre-blockchain era.

Everyone not in the web3 space has urged us to never mention web3 aspects at all when pitching the project, even going as far as asking us to remove hints of it from the website. While it is too early to do so we expected this very early on and "earning" from playing the game isn't our main focus, similar to how our main focus hasn't been the price of our token at this time but rather the funding of the project.

The difficulty of access for players outside of this space, and let's face it, hive still not being easy to get an account to and even if you do, wondering if you want players to rely on losing access to a game they've paid for if they don't save their keys properly or get hacked has often been on our minds. At the same time we also don't want to be liable if we get hacked and players lose a lot of assets in their "web2" mode of playing the game, but those things can always be rolled back if they occur.

image.png



I've posted in the past that aside from offering people "web2" accounts to play the game we would also want to offer potential players trial accounts while making sure those don't get taken advantage of by multi-account/bot/clickfarms thus it'll always be important to keep a good eye on the abuse vector. At the same time making trading of in-game assets and profession materials easily accessible to all accounts could cause for a lot of shady activities and different markets to pop up for each asset which we're also not fans of. For instance, if you're gathering profession materials such as "holo dust" and could easily trade it to your "main account" where you've leveled up professions, bots would have a field-day gathering them on the cheap/ease and sending them forward to their main accounts to create items that may be worth some zing/hive on the markets. This would also lead to market manipulations as we've seen with other in-game markets of web2 games, let alone web3 ones. Lastly it would also open up a world where gambling would be enabled for players of all ages which we definitely don't want to encourage in any way.

While all these things may sound like a lot to deal with, and partially they are, we want to make sure that we make it as difficult and more importantly as unprofitable as possible for abuse and bad behavior to sprout in our gaming ecosystem. Luckily things have taken quite a while to be rolled out so it has given us quite a lot of time to plan them out properly before rolling them out.

Some of our item-variants between what can be traded, what can't be, what can be salvaged, what you can do with salvage materials and how you can trade them, base zing burn costs to most activities that lead to making items tradable and a market fee that'll partially burn zing/hive, partially fund the team and partially give dividends to zing holders will make it harder for abuse to occur. On top of most activity being open and public to anyone to help detecting glitches, imbalance and potential abuse to allow us to nip it in the bud from our side so either the accounts, the assets they've purchased and/or the assets they're attempting to profit off get "soft-banned" from our side to alert potential buyers that we don't allow the items to participate in our ecosystem any longer, whether they're immutable nfts or not.

image.png



There's been a lot of testing of other games in the past with these methods, a couple such examples could be counter-strike and splinterlands. Bots and multi-account farms aren't going to care if there's an entry cost to the game itself when a CS copy would cost $10-20 and getting a splinterlands summoner's book along with a hive account. They won't care as long as they can make a ROI back quick before they get caught/their abusive activity gets patched.

Our focus won't be on earning in general, while player will be able to earn Zing and items that may have value to others, our goal is definitely long term rather than what we've seen in general in this space. Our focus will be in collecting and playing and deciding if you want to burn your earnings to progress in the game further or if you want to stop there and risk getting diluted over time by those progressing further. This is a bit simplistically put of course, but our hope is that the rarity of assets and creatures will be sought after by collectors to make certain items invaluable to them and enjoy having them and using them in a broad ecosystem with long-term view on their value. As an example, people who purchased the first edition of pokemon physical card collectibles didn't instantly try to dump them for a 1.5x gain to the next person a month later. While they weren't able to also earn some "equity" in the project with them and with Zing they may, it took them quite some time to see a nice return on their "investment" and that was only after the project became a worldwide sensation which even after many years remains at the top of collectibles. When we say our vision is long-term, we have something similar in mind but all the while giving players more perks than just the return on one aspect they could invest in when it came to those pokemon packs and we hope that people will appreciate what we're trying to do with the opportunities blockchain offers us which we believe will be hard to beat in this space.

There's a lot of flashy fun things coming out in the web3 space these days, and some are doing things right by not mentioning nfts or web3 all that much, but most of them are also not as web3 as we'd like things to be following the true vision of what blockchain technology wanted to enable. Community funded grassroots projects are a dime a dozen in this space and definitely even rarer in the gaming scene, but we believe that with our connection to Hive and future crowdsourcing efforts we're going to outlast the competition and see brighter days that'll reflect on the differences of our gaming ecosystem compared to the rest out there.

Anyway, I kinda side-tracked a bit here compared to what I was really going to talk about, but there's also some things still hanging which I can't really discuss until they're finalized. What I can say is that the people I've talked to outside of this space really love the idea of Holozing's first game, the focus on artwork and graphics we have yet to showcase to the community and even if they hate the web3 aspect of it as most outside of this space do due to stigma, we're going to try our best to not shove it into every new players face until they opt in the immutable world everything's been running on when they're ready.

image.png

Healer artwork from our amazing artist @craizuss

Sort:  

Man kudos to you @acidyo it's a game that is cared a lot by you and the team, I hope for all the best, i like how your thought-process here, well I am an overthinker so I get the sense of how people outside the crypto space would perceive once they heard the word web3 or nft. ever since the fall of big nft games way back in 2021 or 2022 there's a stigma here in the PH that all nft games are not for a long ride just a short stay to earn some cash. So I just wanted you to know that we all support and pray for the success of this game! Also while grinding for this game stay healthy!

Some of my facebook ,, friends'' are very much anti crypto and consider it a scam. So I have not bothered telling them that I earn crypto here. If they would give Hive a chance maybe they could earn financial freedom here. I even believe that if more people would be into crypto and blogging it could get rid of starvation for ever...But some people rather see the dangers of crypto instead of opportunity. I don't understand their way of thinking. There are plenty of phone/ internet scammers but people still happily use those things. But crypto is somehow bad, right?

There are plenty of phone/ internet scammers but people still happily use those things.

This is what gets me the most I think. It is so true. People see crypto as this magical scam that is nothing but and ignore it as a technology. It is sad.

I think, like you also said, earning shouldn't be the main focus of a game, even in web3. I think that if the game is good enough and people find it fun enough to collect/engage with it, there will be profit opportunities, given a free market situation. But the game itself does not need to necessarily focus on making money, but making fun.

People seem to forget how many games these days cost an arm and a leg and then the creators just book it as soon as it stops being as popular, leaving a broken game that can't even be played, because the servers are down.

There have been a lot of scam games that are Web 3 and play to earn. There have also been a lot that just aren't that fun. Or ones that were okay but the creators made a bad decision down the road.

The true question is the cost to you and if it was fun. If it cost $50 and wasn't even fun, then that sucks. But if the actual cost is only maybe $5 or $10 and maybe you actually made that back and had fun, then I think it's definitely worth it.

There are also a lot of games with online assets that just eat your money...

Holozing seems to be on the right track, avoiding the mistakes of its predecessors. Splinterlands could have been better if not for multi-accounts and bots which were not only allowed but encouraged at the start of the project. Then CL cards were overprinted together with other side projects (Soulkeep, Land) that distracted the developers from core gameplay led to our current situation in Splinterlands. Holozing looks to have great promise and I hope it can live up to its potential and be the new flagship project that brings people to Hive.

We're still far away from being compared to many games to be honest, but we're hoping funding and the pace picks up in the near future!

The artwork is stunning, I must say ... @craizuss, well done ... I'm not a gamer, but I must say Holozing is tempting.

Yeah he's been an amazing find and so glad he's stuck around for this long! Excited to see what else he does for us in the future!

I don't quite get the stigma held against web 3 games, but the challenge it poses to the existence of the Holozing game is considerable and I hope the team finds ways to overcome the obstacles. Providing web 2 access to the game is a good idea. It's also good the Holozing team is taking their time to perfect the project. That will no doubt help in making the game a massive success. Thanks for the update on your progress so far.

There are many difficulties right now but let's hope that in the near future everything that implies a setback can be a strength in WEB3

For me it comes down to

  1. The game needs to be fun but also not require over a hour of gameplay each day. Quick battles or quick things I can do are optimal.

  2. The game needs to earn me something while being fun. A combination of these two things will blow web2 games out of the water.

  3. The game needs to generate revenue outside of just pack sales. It needs external revenue streams. Sponsored tournaments in which sponsors pay to have their name on the tournament is just one of many ways to build revenue that supports the game but also the value of the cards and tokennomics.

Hi, @bitcoinflood,

This post has been voted on by @darkcloaks because you are an active member of the Darkcloaks gaming community.


Get started with Darkcloaks today, and follow us on Inleo for the latest updates.

Congratulations @acidyo! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)

You published more than 2200 posts.
Your next target is to reach 2300 posts.

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Check out our last posts:

LEO Power Up Day - October 15, 2024

dang I'm not even at 75% of 1 post per day since I've been here.

It's all about consistency and finding a pace that works for you. Even if you don't post one post per day, the quality and engagement of your posts matter just as much.

Great, how do I get into the game before it's released?

PIZZA!

$PIZZA slices delivered:
@danzocal(1/10) tipped @acidyo

It would be great to have another breakout game like Splinterlands on HIVE. Hope Holozing makes it even bigger than Splinterlands. All would benefit on Hive from it.

and they are going to achieve it my friend, making the #Holozing game independent is just a matter of patience to achieve it since they have a great team that is working hard to achieve it and make this the best game for Web3

These really look amazing.... They look like they could be scary!