You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: SPS Governance Proposal - Burn NFTy Decks

in #spsproposal • last year

I'm fully onboard with this. Remove them and burn them like was agreed upon when this was set up. I disagree that they are not hurting the ecosystem by sitting there. Even if its just morale when looking at the number of circulating copies when thinking about buying a card. Perception is everything.

Card owners are free to create decks and lend them to NFTy. We definitely have enough cards floating around that need to be put to use. The more of the card base that's being used, the better. So let's use cards players own instead of this ghost deck.

Finally, the partnership did fail. NFTy told us they would be onboarding tons of players with those decks. It wasn't set up as we'd send players over. They told us they had big plans and were signing huge guilds and all the stuff. The deal was that we lend them the assets they need and they onboard hundreds or thousands of new players.

When Aggy suggested this we agreed based on NFTy's ambition and reach and because Aggy said if it didn't work in a few months, we'd burn the cards so there was nothing to lose. Its been a year. It failed. So let's follow through and burn the cards.

last year in #spsproposal by
$0.00
    2 votes
    Reply 2
    Sort:  
  • Trending
    • [-]
     last year (edited) 

    Also, when did these become DAO owned cards? Chaos Legion had nothing to do with the DAO. These were lent by the company. Why would the DAO get the DEC? Am I misremembering something?

    These need to be burned and then the DEC needs to be burned. When we voted to burn these packs, there was no DEC coming out of it. There shouldn't be DEC now just because we opened them. When we voted to try this, the deal was if it didn't pan out in a few months, we'd burn them and its like it never happened. Adding 70 million DEC into circulation/the DAO coffers, wasn't part of it.

    [-]
     last year (edited) 

    I agree with Imno. 500'000 CL packs were transferred to NFTY! 500'000 packs (which should have been burned according to the DAO vote btw)! This is 3.33% of the total CL packs supply.

    About 440,000 CL packs were opened resulting in the minted of:

    1. 36,038,870 CP - nftybronze account
      31,316,870 CP - nftysilver account
      So it's clearly not only 20 decks. Probably 20 decks are available for rent and other cards are just sitting there.

    2. 60'000+ CL packs were never opened and are sitting on the balance of the nftybronze account.

    imo above mentioned packs/numbers are hurting to an already oversupplied/overprinted set.

    Moreover,

    • Do we really think we need to keep 500,000 (already minted cards+unopened CL packs = 500k) CL packs for the NPE? 500'000 packs?
    • Are we sure that these cards will be relevant (won't go to wild for example) when this long awaited NPE happens?

    P.S. Sorry all for my paltry 50 cents.